How To Make Witch Finger Cookies
Whisk together all the dry ingredients in a large bowl.
In a separate medium bowl, whisk together the wet ingredients.
Pour the wet mixture into the flour mixture and stir until you have a well-mixed dough.
Chill the dough for 1 hour in the fridge.
Preheat your oven to 375 F. and line cookie sheets with parchment paper. I used a quarter-sized baking sheet here, but a standard half-size works well too. My pans are pretty thick, so if your pans are on the thinner side, you may not need to bake these as long. Keep an eye on them.
Roll walnut size pieces of dough into long sausages and lay them on the cookie sheets. Give them some room because they spread. And make sure they arent too thick or youll end up with monster fingers instead.
Press a sliced almond into one end of each cookie to create the fingernails. The nail doesnt have to be perfect, it can be slightly chipped. It just looks spookier that way!
Using a sharp knife, cut shallow cuts into each cookie to create the knuckles.
Bake for 20 minutes, or until they are golden brown.
Free With Orders Over $75
Get it on time! Place your order Mon – Thu by 3:00pm ET**.
** Orders placed after the above time-frames, will be safely stored in our warehouse freezer.
** We do our best to get orders shipped the same or within 1-2 business days from when the orderis placed. Order processing is dependent on order volume received and our ability to process on any given day.
**Katz Gluten Free will be provided updated shipping services and reduced overnight shipping pricing for the summer season . Visit our Our Policies page to learn more.
To Be Honest This Concerned Me Because I Immediately Thought That The Texture Was Going To Be Too Crispy And Too Hard
After all, if they had just gone from my grocery cart to my kitchen counter and shattered like fine china, how would they hold up when I crunched them in my mouth?
I found one of the fourteen cookies that wasn’t broken and grabbed it from the sleeve.
While the Ginger Zingers smells good like a regular cookie there’s not much of a zingy ginger scent.
To my surprise, there were little chunks of candied ginger in the cookie. The rest of the cookie was extremely crunchy, but unfortunately, it didn’t taste anything like ginger.
Is it still delicious? Yes. Would I call it a Ginger Zinger? Probably not.
Read Also: Are Ricola Cough Drops Gluten Free
How Do I Know If Theres Gluten In Cookies
The easiest way to find out if there is gluten in the cookies youre looking at while perusing the snack aisle at the store is to flip the package over and look at the ingredients list. Look for the terms flour,enriched flour, or wheat flour.
Just about any cookie that has the term flour without any more descriptors in front of it will contain gluten. Enriched flour is made from wheat and therefore contains gluten. Wheat flour comes from wheat and therefore contains gluten.
The only times youll see the term flour on an ingredient list and its safe for a gluten-free diet is when the type of flour comes from a gluten-free grain. For example, rice flour is made from rice, so it is gluten-free.
Other examples are corn flour, sorghum flour, millet flour, potato flour, cassava flour, or chickpea flour. If you know a grain is gluten-free, then the flour that comes from that grain is probably also gluten-free .
Other starches may also be used, like tapioca or potato starch. These are similar to flours, but are also used in gluten-free snack foods like cookies, because they have a light texture and hold up well in gluten-free baking.
The second easiest way to know if the cookies youre looking at in the store are gluten-free is to look for a gluten-free label on the package.
A gluten-free label will tell you that the product contains less than 20ppm of gluten and that the manufacturer has tested this product to confirm this to be true.
Sweet Loren’s Cookie Dough
These are break and bake cookies you can find in the refrigerated section of your local grocery store. The oatmeal cranberry kind are truly amazing. They taste homemade and are so easy to make! Just beware if you make the whole pack. The nice part is you can make as many as you like at one time since they’re break and bake. I make two!
Also Check: Vegan And Gluten Free Snacks
Tips For Making Homemade Gluten
These gluten-free Oreos are incredibly easy to make.
Roll the dough out and use a cutter to cut out the wafers just like you would for sugar cookies. Cut the cookies as close together, re-roll and cut out more. The goal is to cut most of the cookies out on the first and second roll.
You can certainly roll the dough out a third or fourth time, but the cookies will get ever so slightly more dense.
As soon as the cookies come out of the oven, use the bottom of a glass to press each cookie down ever so slightly on the baking sheet. This will smooth out the tops and help hold the cookies together so they wont crumble as easily.
Let the cookies cool on the baking sheet for at least five minutes before transferring to a wire rack. That little extra cool on the baking sheet will help the cookies firm up so they wont fall apart when you try to move them.
After piping the frosting, pop the finished homemade Oreos in the fridge for 10 minutes to let the filling firm up before devouring. These homemade gluten-free Oreos will keep in the fridge for a week or on the counter for 2-3 days. You can eat them right out of the fridge, but I recommend bringing them to room temperature before serving.
Dont Miss: Gluten Acid Reflux
Does Pillsbury Make Gluten Free
Pillsbury, a bastion of gluten-filled refrigerated tubes of bread, biscuits and cookies, has moved into the gluten-free market. The brand, which is owned by General Mills, recently announced a new line of gluten-free products featuring tubsofpizza, pastry and chocolate chip cookie dough. One cookie is 110 calories.
Also Check: Are All Vegetables Gluten Free
Are Oreos Gluten Free
Yes, and no. Most packaged Nabisco Oreos are not gluten free.
But theres the one package of gluten free Oreos, made by Nabisco. Theyre even the cookies we used to make our recipe for gluten free fried Oreos.
That recipe for fried Oreos was really my way of celebrating the fact that Nabisco finally started selling a certified gluten free variety of their famous chocolate sandwich cookies.
When I first developed this recipe for homemade gluten free Oreos, Nabisco didnt make a gluten free chocolate sandwich cookie of any kind. There were other gluten free cookie brands that made pretty good ones, including gluten free Joe-Joes from Trader Joes.
The fact that Nabisco now makes a GF variety, its even more fun to make this homemade version. Theyre not quite as thin as the packaged kind, but I never liked how thin the chocolate wafer cookie is in Oreos.
Our homemade version is richer than the original, since the cookies are made with tons of cocoa powder and even some melted chocolate. And the filling is yours to customize.
Try chocolate or lemon filling. Or dye it a color to celebrate a holiday.
Recommended Reading: Is Lipton Onion Soup Mix Gluten Free
Which Oreo Cookies Are Dairy
This list includes all varieties that are dairy-free , which we can currently find information and availability for. Limited edition flavors often cycle with the seasons, so well keep adding them as they pop up. Online you might see some other unique flavors sold for a premium. Oreo cookies are produced in various versions around the world. But keep in mind that some foreign versions arent quite the same as these American classics.
Also Check: Best Digestive Enzymes For Gluten Intolerance
What Happens If Oreo Gluten Free Chocolate Sandwich Cookies Is Out Of Stock And I Need To Give Specific Instructions
- Find Best Match: By default, your shopper will use their best judgement to pick a replacement for your item.
- Pick Specific Replacement: You can pick a specific alternative for the shopper to purchase if your first choice is out-of-stock.
- Dont Replace: For items youd rather not replace, choose Dont replace to get a refund if the item is out of stock.
by Jamie
The links on this website may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclaimer for more information.
You need an easy gluten free dessert and this one aims to please. Gluten Free Heavenly Oreo Dessert is like, well, heaven. The ingredients are easy to find, the prep time is minimal, its no bake, and everyone will love it. Do you need any more reasons to make it?
How Do They Compare Glutino Sandwich Cookies
The Glutino Chocolate Vanilla Creme Sandwich Cookies are currently my go-to sandwich cookies for a gluten-free OREO substitution. However, as you can see on their review page, consumer complaints have been high over the new recipe of the cookie. The texture isnt perfect theyre thick and sturdy , but Ive been happily purchasing them as they were the only easy-to-find substitute for OREO-like cookies on gluten-free shelves. Theyre easy to find, pretty affordable, and I think taste the most like OREO sandwich cookies apart from actual OREOs. Also, I LOVE their vanilla sandwich cookie version so I wont stop buying those varieties for something different.
Glutino Chocolate Vanilla Creme Sandwich Cookies Cost: $3.72 for 10.5 oz. package
Glutino Chocolate Vanilla Creme Sandwich Cookies Ingredients: Tapioca flour, rice flour, sugar, palm oil, cocoa, tapioca syrup, water, cassava flour, cocoa, potato flour, soy lecithin, natural vanilla flavor, salt, sodium bicarbonate, xanthan gum. Contains soy, may contain milk, eggs, peanuts and tree nuts.
Dont Miss: Everclear Gluten Free
Don’t Miss: Gluten Free Dairy Free Brownies
Sturdy But Delicate Gluten
Once set, these gluten-free chocolate wafer cookies are crisp and sturdy enough to hold a filling without crumbling, but delicate snd airy enough that theyll snap without filling squeezing out the sides. The texture is similar to that of a graham cracker, only softening a bit after a couple of days sitting with buttercream sandwiched between.
To get that copycat dark cookie wafer akin to real Oreos, I use Rodelles organic dutch-processed baking cocoa, which lends color and a deep chocolate flavor . To emphasize the chocolate notes, I add a splash of Rodelle organic chocolate extract, which is my secret weapon for all chocolate desserts.
Also Check: Are Dove Ice Cream Bars Gluten Free
How Do They Compare To Kinnikinnick Kinnitoos Sandwich Cookies
Unfortunately, these sandwich cookies ranked the lowest of the three sandwich cookies we tested. They are very sugar-y and have more of a cake-like taste , more crumbly and sand-y, and were the least like Oreo cookies. While I definitely dont mind buying them if Im in need of a cookie fix, the price and taste arent worth it compared to the new GF Oreos .
Kinninnick KinniToosCost: $5.15 for 8 oz. package
Kinninnick KinniToosIngredients: sugars, non-hydrogenated shortening, pea starch, potato starch, white rice flour, cocoa powder, tapioca starch, water, pea protein, salt, natural flavor, pea fiber, sunflower lecithin, inulin, sodium bicarbonate, modified cellulose. May contain eggs
Read Also: Gluten Free Pizza Delivery San Francisco
Gluten Free Heavenly Oreo Dessert Recipe Notes
A food processor makes quick work out of making cookie crumbs. Other methods, such as placing the cookies in a zip top bag and crushing them with a rolling pin works as well.
Mixing the cream cheese and pudding together before slowly mixing in the milk keeps the mixture from splattering too much.
Folding in the whipped topping by hand keeps the dessert light and airy.
Sprinkling the cookie crumbs by hand allows for even coverage on top of the dessert.
Swap out the vanilla pudding for chocolate for a different taste and recipe.
The first time I made and tasted this recipe, I knew it was going to be one that I needed to keep handy so I could make it again. I hope you give this recipe a try and enjoy it with your family.
Find even more on and .
Last I Tried Tate’s Bake Shop Gluten
I’m a big fan of anything made with ginger, whether it’s straight gingerbread, ginger ale, or savory dishes with a ginger component. I think it’s a wildly underrated ingredient and it should be used in recipes more often!
The Ginger Zingers come in a cute, old-timey lunch sack-type bag, and the packaging is simple and classic. Definite A+ on branding.
However, I was disappointed to see that many of the cookies were broken when I pulled the plastic sleeve out of the bag.
Read Also: Is Tito’s Gluten Free
About Gluten Free Cookie Brands
If I’ve learned anything from my gluten free journey it’s that just because one product is delicious doesn’t mean every product the brand creates will be delicious. It’s a true but unfortunate fact.
There are however some brands that rise above the rest in terms of flavor and texture. I will be sure to mention which ones fit that criteria below otherwise here are the best gluten free store-bought cookies that made the list:
Where Can You Find The New Gluten
You can find them nationally starting NOW! Readers have had success finding them in Walmarts across the US, especially in the east coast. Nationwide rollout is starting up, so stay tuned to your favorite stores for GF Oreo cookies to be popping up near you!
They currently retail for $3.67 for a 13.29 oz. package .
You May Like: How To Know If Something Is Gluten Free
What Are The Ingredients In Gluten Free Oreos
According to Nabisco, the ingredients in gluten free Oreos are:
sugar, white rice flour, tapioca starch, palm oil, canola oil, whole oat flour, cornstarch, cocoa processed with alkali), invert sugar, soy lecithin, baking soda, salt, xanthan gum, chocolate, artificial flavor
Youll notice that one of the ingredients is whole oat flour. Although oats are gluten free when theyre sourced properly, Nabisco doesnt specify that their oat flour is made from certified gluten free oats.
However, Nabiscos gluten free Oreos are certified gluten free by the Gluten Free Certification Organization . The GFCO is a program of the Gluten Intolerance Group, or GIG.
How Do I Know If Theres Dairy In Cookies
Similar to gluten, youll know if the package of cookies youre looking at at the grocery store contains dairy is to review ingredients lists. Look for obvious and less obvious names of dairy, like:
Another way to know if the product contains dairy is to look for a note under the ingredients list that says Contains Milk or Contains Milk Products. This will help you determine if you should avoid this product on your dairy-free diet.
Finally, some cookie packages have the terms dairy-free or non-dairy or free from dairy on the front. Though these terms are not regulated by the FDA, those that do include them are trying to be helpful to consumers.
But dont take them at face value, review ingredients lists in addition to seeing this label to double check before buying.
Read on: Are chocolate chips dairy-free?
Recommended Reading: Trader Joe’s Gluten Free Pancake Mix
The Gfb Dark Chocolate + Coconut Bites
These sort of remind me of Larabars except in convenient little bite sized balls. They’re sweetened with dates and brown rice syrup. They’re also soy-free, vegan, and kosher. These aren’t overly sweet and have a nice chocolate flavor. They’re rolled in coconut flakes which pairs great with the chocolate.
More Gluten Free Desserts
Check out these other easy gluten free desserts.
Gluten Free Chocolate Cream Pie A rich and creamy pie made in a gluten free vanilla wafer crust. This recipe is a classic!
Easy Gluten Free Apple CakeAnother recipe that usesgluten free cake mix with pie filling for an amazingly easy cake thats moist and full of fall flavor
Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Bundt CakeThis Chocolate Chip Bundt Cake uses shortcuts like cake mix and instant pudding for an easy chocolatey dessert.
Easy, No Fuss Banana PuddingAn easy recipe that no one will know that its gluten free.
Gluten Free Peanut Butter PieAn easy no bake pie with a favorite flavor combination thats rich and decadent.
You May Like: Does Chicken Stock Have Gluten
Also Check: Dr Schar Gluten Free Bread
Sun Tropics Coco Rolls
These cookies are slightly sweet and dangerously delicious. They come in three flavors – original, salted caramel, and espresso. They have a light, crisp texture and only 130 calories for 10 pieces. I was hard pressed to find anyone who didn’t like these cookies. They would go perfect with a hot cup of coffee or tea.
Tates Bake Shop Gluten
Tates Bake Shop makes the best gluten-free chocolate chip cookies. Chocolate chip is classic and Tates doesnt disappoint. The best gluten-free chocolate chip cookies are made with simple, natural ingredients, and, thanks to the cookies being cut thin, they pack perfectly for lunch or a snack. Its best to pack these cookies and limit how many you bring, that way you dont eat them all at once! Yes, theyre addicting.
Also Check: Gluten Free Steel Cut Oats Bulk
What Oreos Will Be Gluten
There will be two new gluten-free Oreos available: the classic Oreo cookie and the Double Stuf variety. Both of the new gluten-free cookies have been approved and certified by the Gluten Intolerance Group of North America.
The best part? They will be a permanent addition to the product line! Oreo promises more details as we get closer to 2021, like the list of ingredients and nutritional breakdowns. But what we really want to know is what they taste like.
Well let you know as soon as were able to give them a taste test. Were already counting down the days.
Recommended Reading: Are Dove Ice Cream Bars Gluten Free
